I think that painting, playing music, and programming are deceptive in that they are conceptually simple, but require intense decades of practice to master and since it takes a lot of practice people *think* they are conceptually deep.
-
-
Programming is the same as well when it comes to mastery of concepts in the service of cliches. I couldn't code a video game to save my life, but ask me to make a network protocol, programming language, assembler, or anything about "language" and it's no problem.
Show this thread -
Walk up to the average game programmer and ask them to write a network protocol and they choke and die. Or, how they all use Lua 'cause they can't code their own languages. Or how they keep using C++ for no reason at all. That's not because the concepts are hard though.
Show this thread -
It's more that you have limited time and you get paid to perform and what people pay for is cliches that are known to work. So, we all focus in a genre and master the application of the concepts to cliches that work, and branching out requires re-learning all new cliches.
Show this thread -
The significance of this idea is this: If these things all require extensive practice to become viable skills, then telling someone they just need to learn the concepts is denying the fact that a vast majority of what makes you a "programmer", "painter", or "musician" is cliches
Show this thread -
And, not just cliches but being able to apply the concepts to replicate cliches. I mean, programmers are fucking notorious as hell for denying people jobs simply for not putting a space before the ( on a fucking if-statement so don't tell me they're ruled by cliches.
Show this thread -
Additionally, I think a lot of the people who claim you only need to learn the concepts couldn't actually list out these concepts. I think most programmers couldn't replicate P" or a Lisp from memory, even though they're simple. I've never heard a designer even say "value".
Show this thread -
Finally, this questions the wisdom that you CANNOT learn the concepts from simply practicing. If you are judged by your skill in performing cliches, and the concepts are fairly simple, but only understood through experience, then...why can't you learn them while you practice?
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
and then there are people like me who do a lot of unproductive excersizes instead of the ones I need to and get seriously flummoxed by the same sorts of things over and over :)
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.