Today is the 74th anniversary of the first atomic bomb detonation, "Trinity." Here's my New Yorker piece on the test from a few years back.https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/the-first-light-of-the-trinity-atomic-test …
-
-
Acoording to me, Gun-Type design stimll have a big advantage. It's the most relable, durable and "free" support design (even a netron initiator is not need). A Country who want ta have an "eternal" dterence (like mine, France) should keep some in the stockpile.
-
I am afraid that you cannot use gun design device as a primary in thermonuclear weapon, so the yield you can have this way is quite limited. Also it allows to use uranium, not plutonium, and most of core will be wasted. It looks to me as bad set of qualities for a French nuke.
-
The idea isn't to use it as primary or to substitue modern warhead (France has thermoNuke since long time). The idea is to have a retalation even if the rest of the force and most support in the country is kaput . The yield in the 20kt range is enought to have a real deterence.
-
I am not sure that such a mosquito bites are sufficient for a real countervalue deterence. Frankly speaking I believe that even biological warfare is more perspective deterence tool. Also it seems that psychological aspect of nuclear deterence is deteriorating in modern days.
-
Not a conter value deterence but something like a personnal deterence. The target is the foreign leader(s) who have to be scared of a retalation may be in 3 month or 3 years (long time after France is destroyed) with a warhead placed near is own home/office

-
Yep, that sounds like Israel's Samson Option. I am sorry but it also sounds impractical. If you can reach some foreign leader with very heavy (tons?) radioactive device, then you can reach him/her with smaller (and less detectable) conventional bomb and/or sniper weapon.
-
Yeah, like Samson option ! The effective range and the "Windows of shoot"of bomb ou snipping is very shorter than a 20kt device... The purpose is not to have a miraculous weapon but to have new option that is not expensive, very easy to build and able to concern foreign leader..
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.