Alex WellersteinVerified account

And yes, being repulsed by the customs of others is not a great look. But again, hardly uncommon, in any time (much less the 1920s). It is hard to be truly, consistently open-minded. (I am sure my reactions to the German "shelf toilet" could be seen as xenophobic. Fair enough.)

But this doesn't make Einstein a *hypocrite.* You can feel these things and *still* fight for civil rights, you can still fight systemic racism, still want the world to be better. The either/or dichotomy strikes me as totally juvenile, esp. when applied to historical figures.

Einstein's public image in the US is as a saintly scientific grandpa. This is bunk and always has been. He was a complex guy. Sometimes in ways that are good (e.g., his defense of civil rights, which earned him a 1,400 page FBI file), sometimes not (e.g., his issues with women).

This is not an Einstein defense. The guy was imperfect and often unpleasant to say the least; that's not new (to scholars anyway). But the way this is being used to frame his civil rights advocacy as hypocrisy is more revealing about the polarization of *our* time than Einstein.

A beautifully balanced set of tweets which pick up on historical nuance which is no longer fashionable. You cannot trivially judge by applying current standards. A similar treatment is needed for Feynman, amongst others, who is being vilified by “modern standards”.

Mm, it's worth talking about Einstein and Feynman here. 1. I think there's a difference between "6 months of a travel diary, selectively excerpted" and "stories you tell about yourself in public." Feynman's case is a stronger argument that his views on women were core to him.

2. Einstein's case is a question of whether being repulsed by foreign people and customs on a trip invalidates your civil rights and anti-racism advocacy. I don't think it does. Feynman's, though, doesn't have any balance to it. It's just, was Feynman misogynistic?

And in Feynman's case, it's hard not to re-read some of those parts of "Surely You're Joking" and not get grossed out. "You Just Ask Them?" isn't pretty. And yes, one could say, it's how men talked about women at the time. Maybe that's true. But still.