Most undergrad classes are functionally "history of x" or "here are some things that are types of x" or "750 names and/or numbers about x," and even the ones that aren't seem to involve working as hard as possible to keep students from doing or even looking directly at x
-
-
I actually think this is a hard problem for universities. People seem to do most of their actual learning when they're either operating under direct mentorship/apprenticeship or building/practicing on their own and/or autodidacting with more limited direct mentorship
Show this thread -
University structure remains largely unchanged despite broad expert agreement that people don't learn very much that way, and I honestly think most admin think undergrads are too stupid for a real education. And anyway, they seem happy to pay 5-6 figs for lectures + bubble tests
Show this thread -
A lot of people *could* hire a very competent expert in their field for 10-15 hours/week to guide a more productive process, but they wouldn't be able to get loans for it, and depending on the field it may be legally or practically impossible for them to work
Show this thread -
If you want my maximally cynical take, it's that I think these places mostly exist to provide certificates to the sort of people who will later become major alumni donors, and the especially brilliant professors & prodigies are no less window dressing than the student athletes
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
This Tweet is unavailable.
-
This Tweet is unavailable.
- Show replies
-
-
-
The Fukuyama effect; or, the illusion of a world of settled questions, in which debate and discussion are pedagogical tools fundamentally “about” the students, not about the topic.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
College for the masses can only look like what it does look like. The Honors Tutorial College at Ohio University is a successful experiment in mentor-based education, but it didn’t scale, and the format seems unsuited to the TE parts of STEM. 1/?
-
In a sense, “inexperience” 〜 “lacks the language to express.” The HTC functioned by handing a reading list to someone who appreciated the gift they had been given, and treated that list as seeds to a tree of knowledge. The enormous reading provided the vocabulary and 2/?
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.