We've gotta confront the fact that a lot of people want the thing they call Science (popular narrative convergence on academic work, actually) to tell them how to do life, and for the prescription to be roughly what they expected all along, while also fully relevant to the moment
-
-
ex: I really like the idea of teaching reading through less-directed immersion. It fits very neatly into my broader ideas about children and learning. But there's a pretty substantial body of evidence suggesting that in classroom environments, it just doesn't work well.
Show this thread -
It took me a long time to acknowledge that I was scouring the work for reasons to dismiss it. And I found them; you'll *always* find them — flaws in methodology, overstated conclusions, etc. But it's still strong work that shows my preferred strategy doesn't work in all contexts.
Show this thread -
I don't love eating humble pie. I didn't tweet about this. I tweet about a lot of things I read and think about throughout the day, but I couldn't sell my brain on that one. "Here's this thing I find only partially convincing that complicates my deeply-held perspective. Yay!"
Show this thread -
When you're trying to incite some significant change in the world, it's natural to want a clean, legible path to doing it. And it's natural to want clean messaging around it. But that cuts against honesty — it just does. And it ultimately cuts against your own preferred outcomes.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
What's your inspiration for these thoughts? Really helping me align my mind this morning.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
Bravo! I tend to decompose these things into 3 axis: 1. The initial conditions; the current state; what we're working with, 2. The means, methods, actions, functions we have to affect change to that state, and 3. The purpose, goal, endstate, future we want to bring about.
-
Science can tell us about 1 and 2, but not 3. 3 is a moral decision. Policy can be about 1 and 2, but which policy is right depends on what 3 looks like. We should listen to understand what parts 3 we can agree on. But everyone's personal 3 is ultimately their own to freedom.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.