You can add location information to your Tweets, such as your city or precise location, from the web and via third-party applications. You always have the option to delete your Tweet location history. Learn more
The speaker — a "scholar of whiteness studies" — is addressing faculty at a college, where as I understand it we accept that disagreement is the raw material of progress, students should be treated like the adults they are & learning occurs w/o anyone having their pillow fluffed.
But it also sounds pretty unobjectionable — and worse, it's the sort of thing you're going to spend too much defending yourself over if you *do* object.
Your typical college student has spent his or her entire life thieving small advantages from idiot captors in order to make passable grades w/o sacrificing every waking second. Think they're gonna pass on an opportunity like "I can't learn because of the environment you created"?
For many college students, the idea that they're responsible for their own learning & for curating optimal environments for themselves is incomprehensible. And after 10+ years of being strapped into a desk-chair & force-fed words like a foie gras duck, is that not to be expected?
I'm re-listening to the doc with a pedagogy-as-gaslighting frame rather than focusing on the social justice elements. It's really well done. However bad Evergreen State's treatment of @BretWeinstein & @HeatherEHeying looks at a glance, it's actually worse. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FH2WeWgcSMk …
A broad observation: people in a hierarchy have a strong emotional reaction when those they internally accept as their higher-ups publicly debase themselves. The nature of the reaction probably varies notably depending on whether they're aggressively climbing or seeking stability
I think most college students perceive the hierarchy in which they and their professors exist to be largely collaborative, and they benefit from *their direct higher-ups climbing* moreso than from climbing themselves at the expense of those higher-ups
So when college students watch their professors debase themselves, repeatedly and consistently, they feel anxiety, frustration, and ultimately *resentment.* We had an agreement! YOU are supposed to be guiding ME, raising ME up, but at every opportunity you're lowering yourself!
I don't think it's surprising that they try to bring themselves under the umbrella of the figures that are capturing the social capital & power, and one way to do that is by attacking a perceptibly weak element of resistance: the few who are neither capitalizing nor capitulating
After all, if the resistance succeeds, where does that leave them? Who knows. Their direct higher-ups have already irrecoverably revealed themselves to be unworthy of their position. There's no going back, which is what the resistance appears to be aiming for.
One implication of this story I'm telling (which may be closer to or further from the truth, but definitely isn't the whole truth): **the behavior of the students is largely a dependent variable.** The table is set by a few instigators & a critical mass of faculty fully yielding
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
