Warren Moore

Ahh, that post is crazy-old! I’m working on new material, but it’s not ready yet. Are you using Obj-C or Swift?

It still works after some tweaking ;) Always looking forward to new material! Metal has really interested me the last few years. I'm using Swift btw!

Cool! So the chief thing to understand is that you can encode as much work as you want into a single command buffer; dependencies (between kernels) will be resolved automatically.

The practical upshot of this is that you can try to encode kernels in-place, while providing a backup copy allocator to minimize allocations, but chaining from the output of one kernel to the input of another—even within one command buffer—should “just work.”

All of this goes out the window if you’re using MTLHeap, where accesses are noted less granularly, but I suspect that for now you’re not using heaps?

Sorry for reviving the ancient thread, but I’m looking for a way to chain MPS kernels on heap sub-allocated resources. Any hints?

The key thing to remember is that you’re responsible for tracking dependencies between resources that might alias. I seem to recall another tweet from you that mentioned fences; are you using them? Have you consulted this sample? https://developer.apple.com/documentation/metal/resource_objects/image_filter_graph_with_heaps_and_fences …

Yeah, the problem is that MPS kernels don’t provide you with MPSComputeComandEncoder, but instead encode themselves into command buffer. That’s why I’m lost at how to ensure chaining order on heap sub-allocated resources. Is there a way to feed MPS a fence to use?