Ugh no. "Panel of respected experts" is as scary as "mob of incoherent know-nothings". Both are tools for authoritarians to co-opt.
Conversation
Replying to
disagree. We had panels of experts in the past -it's what Cabinet is supposed to be. Dismissal of expertise is a problem.
1
2
can it be misused/abused? Sure. But should expert opinion be more heavily weighted than avg on substantive issues? Yes.
2
2
the problem is experts can't tell you anything about the relative importance of various issues that have substance
3
experts= worse than useless in figuring out the right thing to do, useful only in figuring how to do the thing right


