8/ The conceit of progressivism is that education choices are human-dignity affirmations for which societies should shoulder all risk
Conversation
Replying to
9/ What when this thing melts down? Neoliberals will want the banks bailed out and the debtors abandoned. Progressives will want a jubilee.
2
5
16
Replying to
10/ Post-secondary education should be managed as equity rather than debt, with risk distributed across individuals, institutions, society
5
21
43
Replying to
11/ Every human should be considered a startup of unknown future economic value at 14, not a priori a net asset or liability in NPV terms
1
12
42
Replying to
12/ This will of course be wrong at the margins. Prior odds for/against certain people becoming net assets/liabilities may be huge
1
2
8
Replying to
13/ Safety net should be designed with "good" failure in mind for 10-15 trial-and-error pivot opps btwn 14-30. Current: all failure is bad
1
7
21
Replying to
14/ Biggest point of contention in system design: is "dignity" (as opposed to food, shelter, healthcare) a safety net variable?
2
3
18
Replying to
15/ Pointless humiliation (being paternalistically given "food" stamps instead of cash to buy "vegetables" like pizza) should be avoided...
1
2
18
Replying to
16/ But it's a big leap from abandoning designed-by-cronyism-for-cronyism safety nets in favor of cash to thinking UBI can "solve" dignity
2
1
9
Replying to
17/ There's no alternate path to dignity besides earning admiration of the broad slice of society that bets on your value through good work
3
1
21
Replying to
18/ If only other art historians think you're valuable, or only other Ruby programmers think you are valuable, that's not enough
Replying to
19/ If you can't validate you value to the whole society that invests in you through support of a diverse, representative subset...
1
2
12
Replying to
20/ ...you're just part of a weak special interest trying to grow into a large, too-big-to-fail special interest. No different from bankers
3
3
16
Show replies
Replying to
Ruby programmers, by rule, think that only ruby programmers are valuable. Heroku will not host your code unless you sign an oath.
1

