I like teasing subtly related ideas apart. I can usually quickly decide whether or not there is a meaningful distinction and explicate it...
Conversation
Replying to
...but the distinction between 'want' and 'need' has defeated my best efforts for like 6 months.
5
6
Replying to
...Best idea I've had on want vs. need: they are same psychologically at time scales > 1 yr. < 1 yr, needs are h/w accelerated, wants aren't
4
8
Replying to
Huh? It's there in the words themselves -a need is a necessity, a want is a luxury. You die without the 1st, you're sad without the 2nd
3
2
Replying to
yeah, that's what it looks like on the surface, but the boundary gets very grey and psych responses can be counter-intuitive
2
2
Replying to
Example? Do you mean the cases when people didn't learn how to tell necessities from extras (i.e. bad budgeting)?
2
Replying to
lots of examples that are needs at one time scale, wants on another
Replying to
Is it meaningful to distinct permanently? Like a truth value of a sentence - "This is a lie" does not have it.
2
Replying to
'mission critical' assumes a 'mission' but how often have you been on a 'food in next 5 minutes or I starve' state?
1
1
Show replies
Replying to
Simply speaking, need or want is not a permanent property of, i.e., $5. It's a function of it's momentary mission-criticality.
2
Replying to
there are very few situations in modern life where you're actually under existential threat of life v. death.
1
Show replies

