People you like can be wrong. People you dislike can be right. Calling someone "smart" is code for "I like him/her, I hope s/he right"
Conversation
Replying to
..less often, calling someone dumb is code for "I dislike him/her, hope he/she is wrong." Harder to pretend smart is dumb than dumb is smart
Replying to
...so the pragmatic-honest course is to listen broadly, decide for yourself, and then cite the least dislikable proponent of your view
2
2
8
Replying to
agreed, except this can become gratuitous and a major time lag in critical decision making.

