Any “lords” considering the $8 — you’re helping establish a tipping culture here. Shouldering “peasant” risks from impersonators. Everything else is just random bundling extras that have no good reason to be attached to verification status.
Conversation
I’d actually be willing to pay for blue-like backend features that have no visible profile affordances. Selling fun affiliation badges or NFT display ability is also fine. Pretending the platform’s verification responsibility is a status “product” is just deeply disingenuous.
3
4
49
Contra many people's take on this, I don't think the bluecheck was *ever* an actual status symbol. Where it did not actually point to an external credential that needed verification protection, it was a lolcow badge only ever made fun of. The insult was the canonical perception.
3
2
34
Replying to
> [the bluecheck] was a lolcow badge only ever made fun of
hmm I don't think this is actually true. An analogy is yachts: I don't think I've ever heard of anyone talk about yacht owners in a positive light, and yet they still get bought as, and work as, a status symbol.
13
118
52
's ideas are key here: (i) humans are attracted to dominance, but ashamed of this, and so we pretend we're not, and (ii) more generally we've evolved very deep faculties for self-deception
10
118
107
And I definitely remember when *I* got a bluecheck: my system-2 brain was of course dismissive but my system-1 brain definitely felt good about it, and not in a "yay my followers get protected from scams" way
8
107
59
Hmm. When did you get your blue check? Because after 2017 or so you have been the biggest scam/impersonation risk around. If you hadn’t gotten it and I was twitter security I’d probably have enforced it anyway.
1
6
I never even thought about getting it. Seemed completely pointless at least for me. It seemed like a drivers license or passport except no actual use for me or anyone in relation to me.
1
4
I forget when but I think it probably was around 2017 or so. Maybe shortly before the scams started becoming a big deal.
40
114
8
I’m honestly surprised you had any validation reaction at all. By 2017 you were already above the social band where credentials are meaningful.
2
5
I’m also not sure the yacht analogy tracks. Unlike a credential or badge, it’s not *just* a status symbol. It’s a luxury material good to enjoy. Hell, I’d like having a yacht even if I wasn’t allowed to tell anyone about it.
That assumes you’re not paying a large % of your net worth to get it! Kinda like a big house, the signalling is strongest for people right around your “social class”.
1
2
Still, it’s nice to have. Zero material value is a degenerate case. There’s literally no direct material pleasure to be gotten out of credentials. That’s why they print degrees beautifully, make medals heavy, and add nice graphics to NFTs. To graft on a bit of material pleasure.
3


