Protocol nations over network states 🤔
Conversation
Feels like obsession with network effects is a web2 hangover. Protocol effects are a superset. Eg: picking a convention (left or right) for a side of the road to drive on, and letting a traffic rules/norms culture emerge around it is a protocol effect.
3
26
A protocol effect is the confinement of future evolution and emergence to a well-behaved and tractable (for humans and computers) subspace of a larger design space. A network effect is a specific kind of protocol effect that features > O(n^2) growth of a characteristic graph.
1
2
18
Protocols are more basic than networks ontologically. All networks supervene on protocols but not all protocols subvene networks. Supervenience/subvenience is one of my favorite analytical lenses when I bother to tinker with formal philosophy
plato.stanford.edu/entries/superv
2
1
10
Replying to
Supervenience... Total determination by the substrate.
Networks depend on protocols, yes, but total determination? Would seem to leave no room for the physical nodes.
1
Replying to
Really? Seems a bit obvious, but IP stack stinks of counterexample to my nose.
But for sure, no network without protocol. (Though Brexiteers may wish it were not so.)
1

