Conversation

There's a weird adjacency between the urbit scene and the erstwhile refactor camp scene I don't know quite what to make of. I would not have thought there was any harmony in the energies of the two scenes.
1
2
Now of course the urbit scene has thiel-sized up and the refactor camp scene has wound down, so it's an academic curiosity
1
4
But I think I've figured out why urbit leaves me entirely meh, setting aside my distaste for all things yarvin. It feels like the tech stack equivalent of an esperanto project.
3
29
In initial look at it, to the extent I could get past what seemed like perverse and deliberate arcana, it seemed like a ted-nelsonian xanadu style vision. Except it wasn't vaporware pretending to be the One True Thing, but actually getting built. But it still struck me as similar
1
7
Esperanto projects, unlike Xanadu projects, can and do get built. But their success factors resemble those of a church rather than a utilitarian building or bridge. The sacred architecture *is* the project.
3
21
Sacred architecture is on my mind having just spend a couple of days at a major chola temple. Beautiful, but from any practical point of view a thoroughly unusable building. Except the point is not utility but signification of various cosmic ideas/vibes/feels.
Image
1
16
This isn't to say that things oriented towards constructing the sacred as opposed to responding to the real can't succeed wildly. After all, Esperanto failed as a language, but Klingon kinda worked.
3
7
Replying to
interesting because esperanto has a bunch of unanticipated structural problems (would totally read the history of esperanto) but klingon only has to function as far as barking the occasional provocation on a tv show
2
1
Replying to
oh i know what you meant, and it's interesting that the basis for the demand for klingon (ie fandom) is more durable than esperanto (some kind of utopian world-language concept or whatever)