Conversation

If you mix 1 tsp each turmeric, neem, ghee, ginseng, ginkgo, mistletoe, cordiceps, and ayahuasca in a can of Coca Cola and drink it on a full moon, while reciting all your pets’ names, you’ll directly perceive this truth too
2
59
Kidding aside, it’s exhausting the way these self-appointed decolonizers want to muddy all useful categories into nebulous mush in the name of taking down hegemonic patriarchies or whatever.
1
122
Indigenous knowledge can be a distinct useful category and epistemology without trying to co-opt the category of “science” to try and access the perceived cultural power affordances
4
168
In India bullshit “Vedic science” is already a toxic contaminant of grade school education. Study it on its own terms as an interesting category with much to offer, sure. Don’t create incoherent fusions for political gain.
2
93
As a strong Feyeraband-Lakatos methodological anarchist I’m actually highly disinclined to attribute any special epistemic authority to “science” that’s worth lusting after anyway. It’s just the “indigenous knowledge” of 19/20th century globalized modernity.
3
79
Literally the only reason to make up bullshit equivalences like “indigenous knowledge is science” is to reach for the reins of institutional political power.
4
139
Yeah. And besides European heritage people doing this kind of patronizing infantilization, there’s a shitload of self-exoticization and self-infantilization by non-Europeans too.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
This is a form of racism because it treats anything which comes out of indigenous folks' mouthes as amazing and worth of applause -- isn't that how we treat toddlers? It's utterly infantilizing.
1
65
Indian WhatsApp is *full* of bs claims to “science” not just for actual trad knowledge, but newly made up stuff with trad optics. “Indigenous” knowledge made fresh in 2022 after a Wikipedia trawl
2
44
I’m in training for the next phase of the culture war, don’t @ me 😝 Trad is actually a surprisingly convenient catch-all category for everyone who annoys me — actual trads both dominant and minority, and reactionary larpers thereof
Actually abuse of the arguments of SLaS in the sense of meme image above is about 80% of why I resist/am hostile to postrat crowd co-opting ribbonfarm into postrat extended universe. They misread both Scott and my gloss of Scott in service of annoying trad larps.
4
32