I try to think about this sometimes but very quickly lose track with what I am or am not doing under the banner of “visualization” I mean it’s not literally like seeing of course and then train of thought loses the plot
Conversation
Replying to
I mean but it can’t be JUST like seeing , that’s why it’s the “minds eye”
Oh wait
Wat
Ugh here I go again
1
1
4
Replying to
Do you mean to tell me that most people can literally have at will the brain state that is otherwise produced involuntarily by seeing (presumably) real objects out in the world ?
3
1
9
wait i don't believe this is what people mean when they say they can visualize. i think there are two different visual spaces, the "actual" visual field and the "mind's eye," and visualization refers to the latter. i think i ran a poll about this
1
1
some people claim to be able to superimpose arbitrary images onto the "actual" visual field but afaict this is a much rarer ability
1
can't find a poll but short discussion here
Quote Tweet
there are (at least) two different “spaces” at play i think. psychedelic visuals are happening in my “actual visual field.” the rest of the time when i say i’m visualizing something it’s in my “mind’s eye.” like the diff between hallucinating vs. remembering a song twitter.com/_holyweather/s…
Show this thread
3
1
there's like tests for aphantasia and literature on it... your analysis seems like shitpost half-assery tbf :D
from how they describe it, I think normies can actually see fairly hi-fi reconstructed remembered scenes in visual field
the tests i looked up are about the mind's eye so it seems like they still recognize a distinction between the mind's eye and the visual field?
1
Doesn't seem like this is stuff you can sort out through casual introspection and twitter chats and informal undefined terms like "visual field"
the "visual feed" is a deep stack of neural layers starting with retinal cells that can be pwned at any level, not a cartesian theater
1
2
Show replies
if it's that, I absolutely cannot do it, and on those scales with drawings of what you minds eye see I am like bottom fidelity or next to bottom every time
2
That's not how it works for me, at least? It can be superimposed on the visual field with effort, but it's very distinct and couldn't be confused for visual input.
(Admittedly, "normie" does not otherwise describe me, so take this with a grain of salt.)
1



