Conversation

What smaller ticket universal items (ie not cars or homes) would you include in a basket of 5 goods or services (not experiences) as an index of *aspirational* class? For eg: 1. Shoes 2. Produce type (organic/non) 3. Haircuts 4. Moving (self, hired, full-service) 5. Pots/pans
40
33
I’m interested because “lifestyle/consumption advice fail” most often happens on social media because you can’t guess current or aspirational class easily online unless people advertise their consumption choices which is hard to do without being crass.
Replying to
Age is a good proxy. People generally aspire middle class at least and get close to it by 40 or so. The desired/achieved gap is low. Especially for married people.
3
7
Marriage tends to conventionalize consumption tastes. Offbeat-consumption couples are rare. You’re unlikely to have the same weird tastes as your partner, which would lead to shared deviation from normal. Compromise meeting at normal is likelier.
2
16
A confounder is the “trading up” phenomenon where people make out of band purchases/aspire to in specific areas. Golf clubs, purses, are common out-of-band trading-up items so should not be used in an index
1
4
Some responses not quite getting the idea here. It has to be something almost everyone consumes at some quality level. Not something class or subculture specific, nor a class-specific instance of a cross-class category.
4
2
Replying to
art everyone has stuff on their walls, some people have sports memorabilia, some have nicely framed prints, some have an actual Picasso nfts are weird bc they make this consumption public and legible. big part of why I’m anon
1
Replying to
My grandmother grew up w/2 live-in maids & 2 chauffeurs. They owned the most elite girls summer camp & k-12 school in NYC. Everyone on here is signaling nouveau riche, boring & crass. 1. Health w/o trying 2. Freetime whenever & wherever you want it 3. Too busy being interesting
1