Premature evil is the root of all optimization
Conversation
The fundamental error of religion is to assume reality is Leibniz-optimal. That the past is optimized and that we are pre-destined to act in ways that optimize the future. Any apparent suboptimality in either is just your optimal current ignorance. All will be clear in the end.
1
1
6
Leibnizean optimality is my de-valenced term for what is usually called Leibnizean optimism (“all is for the best in this bes of all possible, worlds,” the inspiration for Voltaire’s Dr. Pangloss).
1
6
It’s a sort of teleological principle of least action that constructs reality as pre-determined and optimal without disturbing the notion of free will. Via teleological sleight of hand that requires at least an implicit notion of the divine as a boundary condition to work.
1
5
Leibniz was a sort of clever crypto-apologist for trad religion. Cf his face-off with Spinoza (see the Courtier and the Heretic)
2
8
I’m landing on the hypothesis that if you could actually meaningfully optimize over an infinite horizon (no tricks like discounting or infinity shenanigans), you’d find that reality is actually 100% spandrels.
2
1
8
Intuition behind the hypothesis: increasing abundance is the only assumption that makes sense over an infinite horizon. Anything else reduces to finite horizon. Tricks like exponential discounting encode scarcity assumptions rationalized via a mathematical “need” for boundedness.
1
3
Tldr: Reality is the shitpost stream of absent gods
1
3
14
Now, where shall I have lunch? 🤔
2
1
Evil is only not premature when you know you’re going to live for ever. Wowbagger was rationally evil.
1
The more your resources exceed your horizon, ie live in felt abundance, the more your life will look like a slobby unoptimized mess (but you cannot infer felt abundance from slobby messiness)
By contrast the more beautiful your life conditions the more you live in felt scarcity

