I can suspend belief enough to enjoy time travel, hyperspatial travel, and parallel universe travel, but not upload/download or body-switching premises 🤔
Conversation
Arguably they’re all the same premise (consciousness reconstitution with a different set of atoms) but upload/download transits through a digital representation and dammit I believe in the hard problem of consciousness and don’t think that’s meaningful.
2
13
Replying to
Upload download is like believing you can construct a 100% accurate map with less than 100% of the quantum information content of a lukon of matter, and then regenerate the territory from it.
2
8
I’m not a materialist, but I’m a material irreducibilist. I can sort of believe you can reproduce subjective consciousness if you do somerthing like quantum entanglement of indistinguishable atoms. But “scanning” a brain at the “neuron” abstraction level is just too leaky.
2
10
Need more lossy upload/download stories. Heh if you uploaded/downloaded repeatedly in a loop like photocopies of photocopies, you should start Stepford Wives and eventually get a stick figure animated by a very small shell script.
Quote Tweet
Yes but I can’t thinking any good fiction that exploits that besides perhaps Stepford Wives
3
6
Replying to
body switch with continuity of consciousness is no problem under the premises of the Advaita Vedanta because any body you put together has the same consciousness in it anyway
2
2

