Conversation

Classifying memes on a Cynefin template. With overlaid horseshoe effect between obvious and chaotic. Other candidate classifications welcome.
Image
3
55
I’d say virgin-chad is on border between complex and chaotic, as is screaming woman vs cat (they’re the same idea) “One does not simply walk into Mordor” is complicated Yes chad/Nordic gamer is obvious
1
3
Didn’t notice until just now, but most memes with trad sensibilities tend to be in the obvious quadrant. They point to best practices in a sense-categorize-respond mode, and maintain a chaos-oblivious posture.
1
5
Obvious = deny disorder Complicated = try to overcome disorder Complex = subvert attempts at order Chaos = embrace disorder Center = embody disorder
1
4
How it started/how it’s going is complex quadrant Interestingly, memes don’t convey irony well because they have a context-free/global context character. To the extent a meme can be deployed ironically, you have to suggest irony via accompanying context and subtext.
1
3
Extending to other media, all explainers are complicated quadrant. Most of Substack is complicated quadrant. Besides memes, most media tend to have a single quadrant locus. Blog posts sometimes span all 4 though, which is why they can go viral in ways newsletters tend not to.
2
2
Many memes try to traverse all 4 and end in chaos. Expanding brain is best example of this. Small brain = obvious, Galaxy brain = chaos.
1
3
Memes have turned into our primary sense-making medium for a good reason. Most media have QA criteria that force them into one quadrant. Essays and books tend to have a one-quadrant voice that determines their genre classification. Blog posts can escape but it takes real effort.
1
3
Traversal memes aim to land in their highest quadrant, and construct-subvert escalating notions in lower quadrants. American chopper nominally starts obvious and ends complicated, but the growing discomposure of the actors creates an affect subtext that actually lands in chaos
Replying to
I think the cynefin people have a notion of “narrative fragments” that’s roughly analogous to social media memes. Haven’t dug in.
1
3