but seriously though, the design pattern stuff (according to ) was primarily a failure to transmit the important aspects of patterns to the software dev community, but imo to paraphrase gretzky, they were "skating to where the puck was, not where it was going"
Conversation
The designs he did himself were mostly utilitarian, somewhat trad looking buildings right? I recall you shared photos of the campus of a school or something.
1
Replying to
yeah though the fact that it looks trad is a red herring; ask yourself instead why contemporary architects have to use wacky materials and dangerous-looking cantilevers etc
1
Replying to
yeah so hopefully now you can see the fundamental impedance mismatch: alexander was never trying to make a "statement" with his work like his contemporaries do, he was primarily trying to build something that worked for his clients—he didn't give a shit about getting in magazines
2
2
for every other architect their current project is an advertisement for their next project
1
Replying to
Which is also fine by me. If innovators weren’t willing to try new things on clients’ dimes we’d never get anything new. Faster horses etc. Frontiers always have both fraud and novel shit people didn’t know they wanted until somebody decided to give it to them,
1
1
Replying to
alexander's contract stipulated he could unilaterally reorganize the construction budget; indeed a big chunk of the cost of the mary rose museum proposal was an innovative design for piles so the structure could be built on clay for under £10M
1
1
Replying to
Okay that’s the sort of thing I’d lead with if I were trying to convince people convinced he was trad that he wasn’t…it’s the buried lede
If you turn this thread into an essay, I’d open with that. Took a conversation buried 15 replies deep to get there.
I mean for people hostile to trad stuff (and I admittedly am fairly hostile) the main thing they’re *friendly* to is novelty and innovation and evidence that someone is willing to break from tradition.
1
1
Replying to
iirc a lot of his projects involve some kind of in situ invention; regular use of sophisticated materials and techniques (FEM, shotcrete/gunite); his meta-innovation was stipulating that he didn't have to a) invent up front on spec or b) beg permission
1
2
Show replies
Replying to
yeah arguably the economic/contracting stuff is his most important contribution, but he was using finite element analysis to design roof joists that were shot with gunite
2
Show replies

