Cute, but no. Every generation has a vanguard ‘cool’ that rides a new medium to assert cultural presence, but it basically has nothing to do with elite roles in society, even if a few get rich. twitter.com/farmer_rho/sta
Conversation
This is intriguing but I think flawed. Elite-makers are not elites because unlike monarchs of yore, journalists etc cannot guarantee anything. Their influence is unpredictably catalytic rather than determinative. Same goes for algorithms. Maybe Putin/Xi still have such power?
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Proposed elite definition: You're elite if you get to decide who's elite. Then
1965-2015: journalists — and in particular news anchors. 2015-2019: comedians
2020- : Algorithms (which prefer no one to be elite)
2
1
17
You can see the search for new elites in the efforts to install new virtues (new sincerity, trad, post-irony, epistemic hygiene, climate consciousness) that flounder because they’re like trying to ‘make fetch happen.’ Can’t install new virtues without electing new elites.
4
2
16
Normally the way to model the situation would be to treat this as an emerging elites market with no clear monopolistic winners yet. But I’m no longer sure there IS a market here. It’s worse than crypto. People are only hodling shitcoin candidate-elites and there’s no bitcoin.
4
13
Another sign: apparently everybody turned into an accredited investor in the last couple of years there’s been a glut of “small gods” trying to establish themselves as niche elites (contradiction in terms?) through special-snowflake virtue investing. It’s the new virtue signaling
2
21
How to lose a bunch of friends with a single tweet 🤣
1
19
To be fair, also true of the writerly commentariat class to which I belong. Trawling for new candidate elites to pump up so we can free-ride. We just invest with words rather than dollars. But hard to do with so few candidates around.
4
14
Replying to
Commentariat is out. And that's not what you are.
You're a philosopher.
Would be great choice for the next admired elite.
1
1
So turn the question around: What has to happen to make philosophers the next admired elite?
1
1
My answer follows the famous Marx quote: Die Philosophen haben die Welt nur interpretiert. (=commentariat). Es kommt drauf an, sie zu verändern.
1


