Conversation

I didn’t leave them out. I just don’t consider them elites by any meaningful candidate definition of elites. Historically they were often slaves (eg gladiators, harem entertainers, court jesters). At best they are like divine slaves-to-society like vestal virgins, devdasis etc.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Somewhere you left out athletes. And movie stars. And other populist figures.
3
14
They may become true elites if they make a ton of money and retreat from the limelight (a relatively new possibility created by mass media and royalties/residuals/advertising), but so long as they are servants of spotlights rather than masters, they aren’t elites.
1
11
This is intriguing but I think flawed. Elite-makers are not elites because unlike monarchs of yore, journalists etc cannot guarantee anything. Their influence is unpredictably catalytic rather than determinative. Same goes for algorithms. Maybe Putin/Xi still have such power?
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Proposed elite definition: You're elite if you get to decide who's elite. Then 1965-2015: journalists — and in particular news anchors. 2015-2019: comedians 2020- : Algorithms (which prefer no one to be elite)
2
17
You can see the search for new elites in the efforts to install new virtues (new sincerity, trad, post-irony, epistemic hygiene, climate consciousness) that flounder because they’re like trying to ‘make fetch happen.’ Can’t install new virtues without electing new elites.
4
16
Normally the way to model the situation would be to treat this as an emerging elites market with no clear monopolistic winners yet. But I’m no longer sure there IS a market here. It’s worse than crypto. People are only hodling shitcoin candidate-elites and there’s no bitcoin.
4
13
Another sign: apparently everybody turned into an accredited investor in the last couple of years there’s been a glut of “small gods” trying to establish themselves as niche elites (contradiction in terms?) through special-snowflake virtue investing. It’s the new virtue signaling
2
21
To be fair, also true of the writerly commentariat class to which I belong. Trawling for new candidate elites to pump up so we can free-ride. We just invest with words rather than dollars. But hard to do with so few candidates around.
Replying to
Nobody seems particularly eager to do the messianic sacrifice thing that would sustain a decent pumping effort with money or words.
3
8
Replying to
herein… a clue to the social vector since 2015 (+~10)… an increased immediate feeling of empowerment gave us the ability to consider/research anything, but info culture took precedence over the learning: *the* democratised feeling undermines the elite. tho they’re still there