Conversation

Replying to
They are classes of phenomenology that may or may not be amenable to modeling as games. For example, the scene in A Beautiful Mind where Nash figures out how to get partners for a group by ignoring the prettiest girl is a model of a status dynamics situation.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Social status games/signalling (or is that not considered game theory?)
1
5
Yeah this is a fun bunnytrail. I once did such a model for PD using kinship as a parameter to create a spectrum from pure cooperation to pure adversarial. If PD payoff matrix is P, consider the game defined by P+ λP’... you get fun moving-equilibrium behavior as you vary λ
Quote Tweet
Replying to @christophewllms and @vgr
If you’re trying to map out foundational games, it would be interesting to lay out which hyperparameters tie them together. Small changes in incentives near a boundary on the game map can drive large structural differences.
1
3
🤔
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Sorry if this was already in the replies or doesn't meet exactly what you're looking for but: -Stag Hunt (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stag_hunt) is an interesting variant of Prisoner's Dilemma -not sure if "mother sauce", but one of my faves is El Farol Bar problem (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Farol_)
2
3
There’s so many derivatives and interesting degeneracies this really needs a sort of class hierarchy tree with 5-9 phylla
1
4
There is good raw material in this thread for someone who wants to write a modern intro essay to game theory from a kind of ethnographic salience perspective rather than a textbook perspective.
1
5
It feels like game theory is used backwards, as a class of math problems that have applications. I prefer to think of it as a schema for organizing social phenomenology with a minimalist set of triage models. If you can’t find a model that fits, you have to actually think.
1
17
When I was younger the distinction between zero-sum and non-zero-sum seemed profound to me. Now it strikes me as a high-modernist red herring that gas been overloaded into the philosophy equivalent of factory farmed junk food.
1
5
To snowclone a Michael Pollan phrase, game theory used as analysis results in “processed metaphysics-like substances” Game theory used to organize field observations otoh is interesting. But to do that you have to appreciate variety rather than Nash everything together with PD.
2
5
Game theory may have jumped the shark when that guy wrote that mega thread “time for some game theory” in 2016. It might be impossible for a formalized subject to recover from that kind of muddied thinking abuse.
1
8