Conversation

Replying to
Growing up in India I was taught if you accidentally touch a book with a foot, to touch it with your hand and then touch your forehead. A gesture kinda like crossing yourself (symbolizing apologizing to Saraswati, goddess of knowledge). I think I was ~10 when I dropped the habit.
1
11
I don’t know if kids in India are still taught to do this, but traditionalists are still offended if you don’t. Most parts of the world have a similar reverence if not the explicit ritual. I think it’s an unhealthy reverence.
2
5
To get to the post-textual, post-verbal era, when words are for AIs and humans have to think in post-latent spaces where the AIs can’t reach, gotta get past this kind of reverence. We’re overdue for some healthy disrespect.
1
16
Someday (“when the tonguin’ is done”), we’ll see the age of books for what it has been: the first stage of the creation of cognitive fossil fuels. The real prize is the oil forming inside AIs right now.
2
14
Realizing I’m mildly triggered by any behavior that vaguely resembles prayer without actually being prayer in a traditional religious sense. Actual prayer I can tune out and ignore. But prayer directed at books, constitutions, music, art, Straussian Great Men... annoying.
1
7
There’s some story, I forget source, about a tyrant who promised not to burn a library of a conquered land but got around it by putting all their words in alphabetical order or something. I kinda like the spirit of that story a lot.
1
Books are basically a historically contingent form factor for a much richer collective computing process. It’s a mistake to think that they’re the only UX for the underlying collective stream of consciousness let alone the best one.
Replying to
Death of the author ftw. Mainlining Borg mind stream without the intercessionary figure of the author confusing matters by invoking some sort of platonic realm of idea traditions.
2
5
Imagine a world where memes and gifs and threadthulhus turn directly into Mars rovers and new Rick and Morty episodes without tediously bottlenecking through “books”
1
9
It’s not that they’re going to be entirely obsolete. They’ll just become one specialized UX among many for a subset of hive mind access.
2
4
I mean I’m writing one now (serialized) but only 1 in 3 of my book-sized ideas is also *book-shaped.* And that just shows my age/rigidities (and tbh hangover of youthful vanities). I suspect other things being equal, Zoomers will have 1 in 10 ideas in book form.
1
9
Replying to
Similar reasoning behind oral tradition of the Vedas: "..they comprise rather tonally accented verses and hypnotic, abstruse melodies whose proper realizations demand oral instead of visual transmission. They are robbed of their essence when transferred to paper.." (wikipedia)
1
Replying to
I think this anti-book thread is interesting though I don't agree with most of it. I ingest many forms of media but I still like books. There's a level of nuance/context that can be difficult to piece together from facts but good authors distill/explain in ways that enlighten.
1
Replying to
This discussion reminds me of interactive CD-ROMs. I vaguely remember having a space one and maybe a NatGeo one. Some books came with them. This was just before the internet became popular, mid 90s. Internet experience not quite same as CD-ROMs, tho.
1