All Keanu Reeves movies are pure Campbellian. Point Break, Matrix, John Wick... he might be the most Campbellian hero ever.
Conversation
And nobody has ever come up with a meaningful story structure model that's significantly different from Campbell. They simply increase/decrease the number of points in the cycle, kinda like resolution. The most I've seen is 52 (Save the Cat) and the least is 2 (stress/relief).
7
1
32
When weird avant garde shit doesn't work for you, it's rarely the content. It's usually too much self-important departure from the Campbellian structure.
2
1
36
McKee has a more "literary" breakdown and his unit is more fluidly defined beats and acts, but it's still basically Campbell.
1
15
The only 2 things I've encountered that feel slightly different are Keith Johnstone's Impro model, and Scott McCloud's triangular model in Understanding Comics, which explores a 2d space of form innovation vs content innovation.
2
3
28
That said, I don't think any great storytellers apply Campbellian formulae as their starting point. They tend to develop their instincts through trial and error and get good at telling rough stories, and at some point, they recognize what they're doing in a Campbellian mirror.
1
1
22
Story structure theory is NOT actually helpful for coming up with or writing stories. It's only helpful for troubleshooting and rewriting. The 0-to-1 draft is your problem. Campbell will help you get from 1st draft to nth final version.
2
3
37
Most of the storywriting advice I've seen that's actually helpful tends to be tactical bag-of-tricks stuff orthogonal to structure. Tropes basically. Like: 2 characters hate each other and need to like each other by the end of the act. What to do? Give them a shared challenge.
2
3
23
You need to be familiar with 100s or 1000s of such tropes through consumption of enough examples. It's like a kind of machine learning. Training your pattern generator. Until that's charged up, you can't go 0 to 1.
3
2
34
Replying to
Have you seen Plotto? It’s an encyclopedia of plot ideas and tropes likes these: amazon.com/Plotto-Master-
1
1
1
Replying to
I think so... there seem to be a bunch of such tools. At some point I might even pay for dramatica.

