Conversation

Axe-grinder here, hi It’s not that crackpots are “almost always” right But on “almost every” topic, *some* crackpot is right-er than institutions Crackpot truth high watermark always higher+faster than inst For best results, survey crackpots for best, not institutions for avg
Quote Tweet
The conclusion to draw from 4 years of post-truth is that the crackpots are occasionally right, people with axes to grind overstate the ‘occasionally’ into ‘almost always’ and people who insist too hard that experts should suffer no loss of trust are likely habitual Noble Liars
Show this thread
3
69
Replying to
This is a fairly weak claim. About as strong as the law of large numbers. Like how somebody will guess the lottery numbers right. If you can’t a priori identify the one right-er crackpot, you’re basically saying nothing.
2
5
Replying to
My point exactly. That’s just your guess from 2/20 that appears prescient in hindsight. But there was no way to tell *then* that you were the crackpot to back. The thing about institutions is that they give you a priori cause for greater trust via their average better hit rate.
3
4
Replying to
In theory, greater hit rates are good But it seems like whatever accuracy institutions accumulate on is literally “spent” on big lies at important moments Iraq War Epstein didn’t kill himself COVID “Russiagate” etc Literally every important thing utterly wrong
1
Replying to
Now you just sound randomly conspiratorial. Institutions aren’t monolithic actors. You can still pick up a random paper from Nature and follow the argument and decide how much to trust it. You just can’t do that for random red-strong Twitter thread of vague accusations.
1
1
Replying to and
You’re using Twitter, which is a service resting on dozens of technical standards tediously worked out by expert committees etc. Running on equipment much of which is the result of tedious institutional work. Yes, Epstein didn’t kill himself. No, you’re not vaulting things right.
1
1
Replying to and
The point is, when institutions work right, they do so in boring and quiet ways it is easy to take for granted and radically undervalue. The result is the boring 99% of civilization.
2
6
Show replies