This may seem silly for a thermometer producing a one-dimensional stream of numbers whose meaning is based on stable physics models, but just peek into say climate data debates around temperature records and you’ll realize how fraught this is... personhood is a way to model that.
Conversation
Or take something obviously more complex like a Dexa scan. It produces a data ghost of your body. I got one a few years ago. The tech hands you a piece of paper with a drawing of a human silhouette and color coded visualization of your fat distribution.
1
2
In Culture novels, people routinely save entire states of themselves, including memories, that can be used to resurrect them in cloned bodies or as AIs. Im skeptical of “uploading” as a sentience/consciousness preserving process, but the data-agency take on that is a weaker claim
2
6
The question then is: who owns data-persons created from your data? You the source of the data? The owners of the instrumentation IP? The owners of the copyright on the data model used to cast physical signals like a current valuation into data?
2
5
I think the only solution is: the data owns itself. Just like biological offspring do. Anything else leads to an unholy mess of conflicts of interest, bad faith, etc.
1
6
Like children, data persons need parenting until they get “grow up.” But the principle of fostering ontogenic development into full personhood should be the true north. Ideas like “researchers should open-source data and code used to write peer-reviewed papers” are soft versions.
1
4
This builds on my idea of boundary intelligence from a while back.
Quote Tweet
1/ I'd like to make up a theory of intelligence based on a 2-element ontology: boundary and interior intelligence
Show this thread
1
1
5
See also B. F. Skinner’s famous “On having a poem” lecture where he makes a close analogy between birthing a human and a poem.
1
3
I’m not a data-rights absolutist, and am willing to trade “my”
data for services, but the farther data is along ontogenic path to personhood, the more wary I am of it being locked up. Not “information wants to be free” but “data shouldn’t be in school/jail without good reason”
Quote Tweet
Hey @whoop I’m enjoying your product a lot, but how do I get my data downloaded in some useful format like csv or json or via api/zapier/ifttt? There’s no documentation that I can find or plans/announcements.
It’s almost 2021! Weird to see a consumer health data walled garden.
Show this thread
1
1
8
Galaxy brain version: you’re *already* a data-person yourself. A particular idiosyncratic theory of personhood populated by data streams from about 100-250 lbs of biomass. That you are you is just one opinion about the nature of that mass. quantamagazine.org/what-is-an-ind
2
2
13
Thomas Nagle, 1974: What is it like to be a bat?
Me, 2020: How fo you know you’re not a lichen? A data-ghost of 3 or more beings that just thinks it’s one person 🤣
Replying to
See also... this idea is becoming more popular by the decade.
1
7
