Conversation

🤔 hmm interesting thought but I’m not sure I buy this entire;y... they’re definitely overlapping but not co-extensive. I’ve held and worked from a great mental posture while slouched physically, and vice versa.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @vgr
Poor physical posture and poor mental posture are actually caused by the same thing, which is a kind of 'checking out' - like when you come back to yourself and ask "where was I just now?" So signs might general pattern of tension or 'holding' (doing). twitter.com/m_ashcroft/sta
3
7
Replying to
it's easier to detect shifts than to characterize them, for example, going from whining/complaining about an unexpected shitty thing I have to deal with to just deciding to deal with it. That one would kinda fit your thesis. Usually physical posture changes follow.
1
2
Replying to
I might frame this as: - in whiny mode, the idea that you might be able to just deal with it is outside your awareness (compressed). You are 'stuck' in whiny mode. - for some reason your awareness expands to include 'just doing it', which then becomes available to you as a choice
2
2
Replying to and
Physical posture also follows this awareness state. Compressed awareness, e.g. not 'being able to notice' that there is space around you, leads to your body unconsciously shrinking as if to fill the smaller space. These two are the same thing, but manifest differently.
1
2
Replying to
I think this account leaves out simpler forms of noticing. For example, "whiny" is not hard to notice once you learn early in life what "whiny" sounds like. Even when in bad posture you are aware "I'm being whiny" but sometimes you choose to stop, other times you don't.
2
2
Replying to and
even simpler. Somebody tells you "stop whining" and you decide they're right and... do it. ie, I think mental posture is both easier to program, and can be programmed in more ways than physical posture, and physical posture can follow rather than lead for the right personality.
2
1
Replying to and
Possibly you're over-indexed on alexander technique/somatic awareness and cases like acting, public speaking, interpersonal interaction etc. I'm mostly overindexed on thinking inside your head with low external signs. Like writing or doing math.
Replying to
Possibly, but I'll counter that I am an energy consultant and STEM nerd first and foremost (though shifting) and I apply this to writing and doing math also. I guess I can but assert that the physical and mental are one process - at the very least it's something to play with.
1
1
Replying to
I mean I don't disagree. I'm not a dualist. But I buy that at a level that's unhelpfully tautological. Once you discretize that tautology into a rough operating distinction between mind and body, you get interesting questions/answers.
1
2
Show replies