Philosophical interestingness ranking of sci-fi universes (in terms of meaningfulness, complexity, intelligibility...): 12. Star Wars 11. MCU 10. Doctor Who 9. Dune 8. Star Trek 7. Foundation 6. Deepness in the Sky 5. Hainish 4. Schismatrix 3. Rick & Morty 2. HHG 1. Culture
-
-
Read the first volume. Didn’t strike me as philosophically interesting outside of a couple of points (dark forest theory, psychology of an unstable world) though the story is very imaginative.https://twitter.com/ethicallorax/status/1318054423717838849?s=21 …
Show this thread -
Futurama is a lot of fun but even I’ll admit it’s not philosophically interesting. It’s just fun. My list is correct and profound. If you disagree you are wrong and should feel bad.
Show this thread -
No accident that the top 3 have a strong element of humor and absurdity. Most universes do poorly on the philosophical interestingness test by not taking that element seriously enough.
Show this thread -
Some start out interesting but then go meh. Firefly universe was interesting until I saw the confederacy-apologia angle and couldn’t unsee it. Still interesting as a story but dull as philosophy.
Show this thread -
Hyperion was very interesting but in a very narrow way around the Shrike as a philosophical Rorschach test. I read only one volume. Wasn’t inspired to read the rest when the first one totally punted on actually resolving the Shrike plot
Show this thread -
People hating on R&M bring so high, I get it. To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Rick and Morty.
Show this thread -
Unpopular opinion but Dune is below Star Trek because it is pseudo-deep and too impressed with itself. Premium mediocre intellectualism. Star Trek is middlebrow and knows it. Self awareness gains big points on my scale.https://twitter.com/ykgoon/status/1318059482048385024?s=21 …
Show this thread -
I think I like 2nd order worlds that subvert first-order ones. Like Dune is too primal-archetypal to be interesting. But the interesting ones need them to have something to subvert. Dune parody references are more interesting than Dune itself.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Think Vinge is underrated here. Superior to Banks, actually.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.