Now, in our late industrial mode, with hyperspecialization, the world is not super resistant to high death rates. Which means even small death rates can do a lot of damage. Especially in clustered breakouts which might take out key civilizational widgets.
Conversation
If everybody is either a farmer or warrior in a 9:1 ratio say, the world can tolerate a lot higher death rate than when there are a few dozen artisan trades. And when you get 10s of 1000s of literate roles doing highly specialized things... even small uptick in death is very bad.
2
5
47
I think this could be computed to allow normalized comparisons across history. Like maybe 1 random extra death today is as damaging as 10 random extra deaths in 1918 and 100 random extra deaths in 1348?
1
1
25
Though sheer larger population could have confounding effects
1
16
Note, it’s not death rate itself that causes a problem. It’s death rate and backfill delay. The higher the skill level, the longer it takes to backfill.
Another confounding variable is the residual high-r jobs under the api. And whaddya know, they are the ones risked the most.
4
2
40
But there’s also high K roles under high risk, like specialized doctors.
Sol this hypothesis has a lot of details to be worked out. It’s not a simple, elegant theory. It’s a messy heuristic for mapping system survivability in terms of soecuslization/redundancy/r/backfill
2
23
Note that severe labor shortage was one of the effects of the Black Death. Already by them society was specialized enough it couldn’t tolerate the death rate. Society collapsed quite deeply.
3
34
This Tweet was deleted by the Tweet author. Learn more
Replying to
I suspect it is nonlinear in death rate. Fungibility at an annual 30% turnover rate does not mean fungibility at monthly 10% for eg. The training costs and time alone for even a simple job start to mount and drag
This Tweet was deleted by the Tweet author. Learn more
Replying to
Yeah that’s why there’s serious coercive pressure being applied on labor to return to work in meat industry for eg. They couldn’t handle serious absenteeism. Takes time to automate or backfill and meanwhile animals are still piling up as a slaughter backlog.
Replying to
y the meat industry is one of the most revealing + absurd parts of all this. this thread is super interesting:
Quote Tweet
I do not suggest that this ethical terrain is preferable, but it is definitely the terrain on which animal liberationists must pitch their battle and it is why I am focused on reproduction and breeding as a vital problem of industrial meat and animal welfare.
Show this thread
1
7


