Conversation

Academia: Spend your life absorbing everything that's ever been said about a topic in order to hopefully add a tiny increment of original thought to it Tech: Disregard everything that's ever been said about a topic and confidently rediscover other fields' most basic ideas
8
340
Replying to and
Speaking as someone who has spent about a decade in each world, I’m pretty confident (heh!) that the problem is not that tech under-indexes on originality but that academia under-indexes on importance.
1
5
Replying to and
90% of academia’s originality claims are no more than squatting on easily rediscovered trivia and attempting to derive rents from teminological seigniorage based on versions of ideas that aren’t actually as well-adapted to field use as field-rediscoveries.
1
13
Replying to and
It’s basically an institutional cousin of appropriation complaints culture crossed with a cousin of patent trolling culture (which I’m also generally cynical about)
1
5
Replying to
i absolutely agree with that. i felt like i was criticizing tech more than academia when i wrote this tweet but they are both deeply flawed in different ways, and under-indexing on importance is a real problem from what i can see at a distance
1
3
Replying to and
one point i have that follows from this is that there are certain kinds of knowledge tech won't develop (particularly humanities stuff) bc it will keep rediscovering the same ideas (hence the narrow fetishization of certain books, etc). that's fine, but tech folks keep trying!
1
2
Replying to
I would argue that a lot of “humanities discoveries” aren’t actually discovered at all, just discussed in an ingroup language devoid of any live context. The claims amount to “we’ve talked about this and we demand you learn French and join our conversation”
Replying to and
There’s some insight porn fun to be had there cf stuff like holey plane and smooth and striated etc, but actually “discovering” something involves entangled analysis/application insight. Analysis is not separable preprocessing. Analysis-synthesis separation happens post-hoc.
1
2
Replying to
yeah. i suppose that academia has made much of its knowledge too esoteric/irrelevant to be accessed by the outsiders like tech even if they wanted to
1
1
Show replies