Conversation

About a quarter of the conditions in the DSM-IV seem to be charismatic conditions. Like charismatic megafauna. The stuff that people like to self diagnose and other-diagnose both close-up and at a distance. And construct pop narratives around.
2
19
There doesn’t seem to be meaningful “treatment” for most charismatic conditions in their non-extreme forms. Which makes me wonder whether they should be labeled conditions at all or treated as personality types. Maybe any personality type carried to an extreme is a condition.
Replying to
This is a version of the arguments proposed by RD Laing, Foucault & the old left “anti-psychiatry” movement. They added that the pathologization of these traits was (nothing but) a repressive effort to impose bourgeois behavioral & cognitive norms on all, masquerading as science.
1
2
Replying to
Yeah I’m familiar with that reading but I think I give the profession the benefit of doubt overall as genuinely describing and treating real conditions. Charisma is an additional reading rather than a substitute reading for me.
1
Replying to
This is almost certainly true. It is most obvious with the "personality disorders" - the parallels with Big-5 traits or whatever lens you want to use are clear. A lot of them are quite useful in certain situations, they're just hyper-specialized and not always useful.
1
1
Replying to
yep. if you just stop to think about it anything that isn't within a very narrow set of social norms is abnormal behavior. abnormal behavior is often perceived as very disruptive and potentially dangerous--in reality it is usually harmless and marginal
2
Replying to
I really like the word "neurodiversity", & the argument that this carries from it, that "neurotypical" doesn't exist, and we instead live with a broad spectrum of larger & smaller gradations of difference in brain architecture.
1
Replying to
Well, plenty of physical traits expressed to some extreme degree are, or would be (if sufficiently extreme expression was "out there in the wild") deemed pathological, so I see no particular problem there