It’s the opposite of the mock shock affected by sophisticated cynics at revelations they consider not shocking st all, the “I’m shocked, SHOCKED” line that nobody uses these days in non-mocking ways. Maybe opposite of Mock Shock is Rube Revelation?
-
-
If both sides are 90% noise, do the math. About 81% of the time both sides are being stupid, 9% of the time one side is right by accident and the other side is bothsidesing out of stupidity or malice. About, 1% of the time it’s a great truth in contention. By accident probably.
Show this thread -
Signal-siding is basically ignoring the stupid people, and continuing to actually think, even at the risk of perhaps missing the 1% great-truth debates. Centrism is stupid or disingenuous because it acts like bothsidesing is meaningful 99% of the time instead of 1%.
Show this thread -
Noise vs noise does not net to signal via mutual cancelation (heh!), it is noise squared. Signal is neither consensus or heresy by cosmic preference. Nor is it common sense or esoterically technical by preference, Signal is indifferent to self-important epistemic posturing.
Show this thread -
The truth, such as it is, does not lie on the Rube Revelation spectrum at all. And smart elites who should know better but act like it does, raising mook armies and winking at the snowballing crackpottery and Maoist trials of their rivals among the elites are just seeking power.
Show this thread -
If vast armies of enraged rubes rally around you, celebrating how you, the Rare Good Elite are absolutely tearing apart those awful Typical Bad Elites, you’re probably not catalyzing a Great Consciousness Raising among the masses. You’re cynically making a play for more power.
Show this thread -
Basically, in this environment, anyone who attempts to shape opinions on a large mass-media scale, pwning millions of minds to coerce hundreds of millions of minds into ideological submission, is basically a bad person. It’s as clear a tell as pouring gasoline into a fire.
Show this thread -
When you avoid the temptation to traffic in the Epistemic Status: Rube Revelation idea economy, you will find your audience hitting a low ceiling. Signal-siding in a noisy environment is like trying to have a conversation in a loud party with blaring music and drunken brawls.
Show this thread -
Only the 5 people next to you and straining to understand you above the noise are signalsiding whatever you are saying. If the whole room hears you above the noise, music, and brawling, almost certainly you yelled something loud, stupid, and dangerous. Like “Fire!”
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.