Been mulling this ever since banana tweeted it. There's something here that goes beyond mere strategic incompetence (executives choosing not to know how to use the coffee machine) and strategic ignorance (Sherlock Holmes choosing not to know the earth goes around sun)https://twitter.com/literalbanana/status/1008714338574585856 …
-
-
To the extent strategic incompetence also plays a role in your posture, you're also going to have trouble with unskilled and/or necessary activities, like more stringent airport security, documentation requirements, etc. This is Geselleschaft equivalent of Gemeinschaft sentiment
Show this thread -
(threat level ratings, alarms going off, more police around, more paperwork, etc etc).
Show this thread -
But it is possible. It is possible to retreat in ways that achieve this kind of "civil disobedience". You just have to do an extreme escaping-reality type retreat, moving in physical and lifestyle space to where the sentiment cannot creep.
Show this thread -
The degenerate form of this is what I'e been derisively calling waldenponding. A very personal and rather selfish pattern of retreat (if you're otherwise mentally healthy) that has none of the redeeming features of effective civil disobedience.
Show this thread -
What banana is talking about is a broader kind of disengagement that is focused and tactical. You don't retreat from all societal engagement. You retreat along specific information dimensions to deny specific zeitgeist demons the attention energy they feed on.
Show this thread -
Yep. The norms being disobeyed in this sort of retreat are specific "informed citizenry" norms of democracy. It's not a generic self-care retreat. Which is why I think she hit on a very valuable nuance here.https://twitter.com/hondanhon/status/1157357618723037184 …
Show this thread -
If all the political establishment does for their end of the bargain of *keeping* citizens informed is create FUD and push viral-bullshit buttons of all sorts, they broke the contract first :D
Show this thread -
In fact, "informed citizenry" is better understood as "staying informed where they want to keep you in the dark" (in the spirit of "journalism is printing what somebody doesn't want printed, everything else is PR")
Show this thread -
Of course, this also inevitably creates justification for conspiracy thinking. "What they don't want you to know" is an invitation to wild speculation. Duty to stay informed != aptitude for processing it in reasonably intelligent ways.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I think you CAN usefully tune out most of the noise. You’ll see that everyone is talking about Bob Biggins, and from the tone Bob apparently did something that makes Trump unhappy. But you can avoid seeking out articles or learning the issues around Bob.
-
And tomorrow it will be the same thing, only Twitter Left furious about Sally Sitwell. Again, you can just avoid bothering to search for details, and in a day it will all have moved on.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.