Conversation

Material reality has a lot of detail but very little meaning Social reality has a lot of meaning but very little detail Humans want significance: both detail and meaning at once, to feel present and alive. This can be hacked for profit or insight.
1
17
Significance is meaningful detail. Example: “sell the sizzle, not the steak” creates significance out of a material detail (sizzle as I-it) and social meaning (sizzle as socially constructed meaningfulness of food culture eg barbecue)
2
4
A tell of an inexperienced liar is putting in too much or too little material detail relative to the meaning of what is being said. A significance glitch.
2
10
Magic tricks often work because we badly *want* to believe that objects have intentions minds and mysterious agency (meaningful I-you characteristics we want in humans to relate to) but the trick often exploits basic banal I-it physics/geometry that’s a letdown when revealed
1
8
Replying to
Experimental science is the opposite of magic. Bizarre I-it details with no social narrative attached. Like a mentos and soda experiment. Bizarre and fun but not like a magic trick because there are no significant expectations being subverted.
1
6
Our null hypothesis for I-it things is ”nothing much” Our null hypothesis for I-you things is “change caused by living striving” Objects doing something rather than nothing is surprising in a science way People doing nothing rather than something is surprising in a magic way
1
4
Example of latter: a mark picking the card the conjurer wants, due to highly effective suggestion modes... that’s humans acting deterministically like objects
1
1
Try this dumb “magic” trick. Spell out a number of words ending in o-p while a friend pronounces them: c o p cop t o p top m o p mop After 6-7 such prompts, suddenly ask them: “what do you do at a green traffic light?” ~100% of people will say “stop”
1
5
Conditioning structure here is transparent but most tricks with more hidden mechanics seem to rely on similar object-like predictability of human attention trajectory. You work it like an I-it to get an I-thou payoff yourself (people being impressed at a cheap trick)
1
3