About a year ago I gave up trying to define “left,” “right,” “liberal,” and “conservative.”
The concepts are too nebulous, and people have strong incentives to distort their meanings. There’s no stable “there” there.
This has been wonderfully liberating.
Conversation
Replying to
Not a real option. It may feel liberating to give up but doesn’t mean there isn’t a there there or that it doesn’t apply to you if don’t define it for yourself. Even patterns of giving up have left/right/lib/con tells.
They’ve gotten convoluted rather than nebulous.
3
12
Replying to
btw, I’m not saying I’m opting out of choosing a side (although, kinda). Rather, I’m opting out of trying to essentialize the labels. I recognize their validity as flags/banners for the current moment, but not as enduring/stable concepts.
1
6
Replying to
The conclusion I’ve reached is that they *were* stable and enduring concepts that evolved coherently for 150-250 years each, and have all “died” in the last 2 decades. So I half agree with you. They’re not stable and enduring into the future. They’re decaying corpses.
3
6
I’ve described culture war in private conversations as choosing which of 4 funerals of political personae to attend at the end of history. My labels for the 4 corpses don’t line up cleanly with the 4 labels you’re rejecting but are fairly simple mappings. I’ll blog this soon.
1) Pro-Commerce
2) Anti-Commerce
A) Pro-Individual Expression
B) Puritanical
%) Tragic (belief based) Religion
&) Comic (improvisational) Religion


