Urban planning focuses too much on moving people and ritually hating cars and not enough on moving goods breakbulk. If you had to design a major metro today from scratch, you’d probably start with a cargo underground with pallet-sized autonomous EVs and loading bays as base layer
Conversation
This tweet inspired by the utter pain of shedding unwanted large items (area rug, extra table, futon, kitchen crap) in preparation for a downsizing move from downtown Seattle to downtown LA. Mix of craigslist, eBay, yard sale, drop-off at goodwill... from about 1000 to 660 sq ft
Replying to
Suburbs are okay for trucks etc at least. Moving to/from downtown but old buildings without proper truck parking/unloading bays... horrible. Normal adults have stuff, not all amenable to being hand-carried and walked in highly “walkable” neighborhoods.
1
8
I have a feeling high-walkability is partly a NIMBY dogwhistle against transience, mobility, renting. I’ve moved 20 times across 7 cities in the last 20 years. You feel pain of anti-cargo urban design most when moving, not when going shopping or getting a single big box delivered
2
3
13
And note, I’m not a fan of cars personally. I barely drive anymore and would prefer to be carless (wife does almost all the driving). I walk everywhere. But I recognize that cars and light trucks are essential to urban life absent alternatives. Because people own larger goods.
3
12
Serious question: how come the e-scooter companies haven’t explored a city-level streetworthy shopping cart idea? People do it anyway, not just homeless ones. Higher-tech stores put geofenced locks on their carts but the use case for moving goods up to ~1 mile is real.
6
2
20
The shorter the median ownership period of a durable good, the more TCO estimates will be garbage due to very high variance delivery and transfer/disposal cost and illegible logistics snafu PTSD.
Imagine getting a couch in/out of your home every day.
1
5
Need a Coasean economics of lifestyles including a theory of transaction costs of ownership/rental of durable goods, both physical and digital
2
3
Adding this here
Quote Tweet
Pick 2 off 3 triangle for neourbanism
- High geo-mobility renter population
- High-durability/low-waste consumer goods
- High walkability in pre-modern anti-goods sense
Show this thread
1
Replying to
Welcome to DTLA. Made this move two years ago from SF. Hope you like it. Got much better since we moved down here
1

