Conversation

I think there's an important thought here. We tend to treat "markets" as a human cognitive universal like math or chomskyean grammar. The more I learn, the more they seem a contingent institution like say the catholic church.
Quote Tweet
Random snippet I emailed myself a few months ago that I don't know what to do with. --- Markets as culturally contingent phenomena rather than fundamental “Distortion” as the actual information content “Post-European” markets, just like post-Westphalian End of history alt
Replying to
If you allow people to trade social importance and socially-defined obligations, then markets are probably really old. Money-and-contract markets are probably also old but limited in scope. Maybe cash money and markets need each other.
1
Replying to and
Exchange is as old as any record. local barter about the same. trade (production on speculation) prehistoric. markets (production on speculation using imputed prices) as early as civilization (cities).
1
Show replies
Replying to
I would have to understand that with a bit more clarity. Markets are created by use of law to suppress involuntary transfers across the spectrum from the most obviously physical to the most abstractly normative as to decrease costs. (Barter(goods),Trade (money), Markets (prices))
2
Replying to
So in the sense you mean math (positional naming for scale independent measurement), or the grammar facility (continuous recursive disambiguation), exchange is a facility like grammar. But yes, markets are an institutional byproduct of continuous suppression of criminality.
2
Replying to
As far as I know, markets are not culturally contingent, because there is no alternative. If you mean the relationship between subsistence provision, market (voluntary) participation, and non-market (involuntary) participation in production distribution and trade, then yes.
3
Replying to
What we consider 'morality' (the moral intuition) is just the intuitionistic perception of debt and return between individuals and the group, within the limits of reciprocity (returns) and proportionality(group retention).
1
Replying to
uhh, yeah, there were a few hundred thousand years of human history before there were anything like markets. gift and barter economies for most of it. if you actually have to work to overcome the 'market as default' thought, just shows how much koolaid you've consumed.
4