Conversation

If you exclude reading, writing, speaking, and listening (ie use of language, including math or code) as mere table stakes, how would you define “intellectual” in terms of essential non-language behaviors that non-intellectuals typically don’t exhibit?
60
66
Replying to
I see an intellectual as someone who explicitly places his or her writing and argumentation in dialog with a tradition (meaning: sequence) of other intellectuals who have written on the topics s/he is engaged with — references, in short
1
6
Replying to and
Of course, that’s not sufficient. When people think it is, that’s when you get the phenomenon of the poseur or the pseudo-intellectual, who goes through the motions of name-dropping for prestige purposes, but who has little original to add to the tradition.
1
2
Replying to
Hmm, that’s a coherent definition of one kind of intellectualism (traditional/scholastic/straussian). I have a feeling there’s at least a couple of other distinct types.
1
1
Replying to
I think of them as "take only pictures, leave only footprints" people. Some of my friends who have an intellectual orientation towards, and relationship with life, but don't situate themselves in tradition as a first order of business. Only as a side-effect
2
3
Replying to and
It frankly bothers me to ground the definition of "intellectual" primarily in relationships with other people rather than with the universe at large. In my book, it should be possible for Robinson Crusoe on an island to live intellectually (even if it means he doesn't live long)
Replying to
The problem with defining “intellectual” in some fashion other than socially or institutionally is that you end up slipping toward a definition like “a tendency toward abstraction/analysis” — which is pretty much the human cognitive condition, so broad that it delimits nothing.
1
1
Replying to
I don't think that's necessarily as broad as you say. Difficulty of measurement and discrimination does not mean there are no fundamental differences there. For example, people with long, integrative memories who are able to relate current events to events long ago.
1
1
Show replies