I'm increasingly dissatisfied with "smart guy" archetypes or personality tropes. "The Sage", "The Magician", "Spock", "Athena", etc.
Conversation
Archetypally, "the smart one" or "the wise one" is an advisor or teacher. He/she provides information & guidance to the hero, but stays remote from the action. Often depicted as childless, celibate, and/or elderly.
1
5
"I'm valuable because I bring you information, otherwise don't mind me, I'm low-maintenance and detached" is a tempting social role to fit yourself into, but IMO it's a trap & won't lead to a full life.
1
1
10
What if the "hero" doesn't value advice or information? knows something about organizations not being willing to pay for info; it's also been my personal experience. A business that's selling "we can get you the right answer" is limited even if it excels.
2
1
10
What if you're "the smart one" and you're wrong sometimes? What if you have a desire or a talent that has nothing to do with being right? Who are you when you're not being "the smart one"?
1
1
7
The most intelligent people I've ever met (e.g. Fields medalists) are married and have children. But "the smart one" as archetype never falls in love or cuddles a baby.
2
12
Identifying yourself with being "rational" or a "thinker" seems like a bad move, for this reason. Reasoning & thinking are valuable skills. They're not identities or archetypes. Any "kind of person" can think. The uniform you wear can't guarantee you're right.
3
2
15
Identifying as an "interesting" person seems like another trap. Sometimes the truth is basic and not that interesting. Sometimes it makes sense to be passionate, not "interested" in a detached way. Sometimes courage or effort matters more than new ideas.
2
3
22

