There are only 3 real challenges to free speech at the tech level a) the need for CDNs at scale b) distortions of net neutrality c) nation-state firewalls. All other claims are about social governance on private sites, where applying free speech doctrine is a stretch at best
-
-
Beyond a certain scale, you'll need things like CDNs to serve your audience. This means you either have to get into the Internet infrastructure business yourself to keep your reach insured, or agree with their policies to stay in business.
Show this thread -
Level up yet again and you basically need your own country to insure your reach. This is reasonable. You should not expect no-strings-attached access to the attention of potentially billions of people under the same terms as ranting from a soapbox in a 19th century town square.
Show this thread -
Here's the thing free speech fundamentalists don't get about "free" reach technology capable of reaching billions: given what is possible, what it costs, and how many thousands of people have to be voluntarily involved to keep the system running, it is nothing like "public air"
Show this thread -
When you ask for conditions of use of this infrastructure to be the same as the conditions governing Q&A time at a physical townhall in a village in a room with 100 people, you're basically asking "give me a free dictatorship to rule over".
Show this thread -
You're a wannabe tinpot dictator who wants the privileges of being ruler of a country-scale entity without all that fussy trouble of actually running a country and maintaining an army who can make internet infrastructure people do what you want at gunpoint.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
However, these may not be reliable agreements, in that the service provider can unilaterally change the TOS overnight without notice and delete all content posted in good faith under the previous TOS with no possibility for content retrieval by the owner. As wordpress did.
-
And this is fine. If you enter into agreements that give counterparty right to change terms, then you cannot complain when they in fact do so. You can only delete your account. The most you can reasonably ask is to take a copy of your past data with you, which GDPR enables
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.