Okay. I've found it. The absolute culmination of the "we have to build bridges with the far right" argument.
Conversation
Henry Cadbury was a Quaker, and I'm sure he was a lovely man. But wow, was he wrong in a very familiar way.
80
2,688
5,825
Among the anti-fascist tactics Cadbury condemned? Boycotts. He called them "war without bloodshed."
19
1,060
3,180
Astonishingly, Cadbury gave this speech to a conference of rabbis. It was not well-received.
10
683
2,697
Rabbi Stephen Wise (who would, ironically, himself be later criticized for equivocation on anti-Nazi topics) repudiated Cadbury's speech.
12
612
2,282
Another rabbi basically said any talk of "loving" Hitler was pointless sophistry.
3
579
2,250
That same rabbi on the moral and practical necessity for a diversity of tactics:
2
516
1,896
(Same day, same page: American Baptist pastor says the appeal of Nazi antisemitism is grounded not in bigotry, but—I kid you not—economic anxiety.)
40
1,544
3,103
The conference released a statement repudiating Cadbury's both-sidesism and insisting on the moral necessity of resistance to the Nazis.
8
483
1,676
(Just a note: "Israel" in the above clip doesn't refer to the nation of Israel, which didn't exist in 1934, but to the Jewish community.)
8
266
1,419
Here's the original article on Cadbury's speech.
5
371
1,097
And here's the follow-up article from the next day from which the rest of the above clippings were taken.
2
292
984
A nice summary of the blowup from a broader article on the conference that appeared a day later:
7
303
1,067
Just going to leave this here in case any of you can think of good uses for it.
18
340
1,356
Gonna have some more thoughts on these articles tomorrow. Stay tuned.
11
63
678
Here's my thread of musings on the above articles, as promised.
Quote Tweet
So I had someone say to me yesterday, in response to this thread, that it was a strawman because we all agree that being reaching out in dialogue to Nazis is bad. A couple things on that.
15
135
613
Since this is blowing up again: I included links in the above thread, but if those don't work for you, the articles discussed are from the New York Times, June 15 through 17, 1934.
26
125
638