We need to have a talk about aerodynamics. This is from “How It Works” magazine.. but this is never going to work.pic.twitter.com/UYp7LAciqY
Show this thread
If you don’t see what I see: imagine either item hanging from an awning, like a shop sign. Any breeze would cause a huge amount of blowing around. Now remove the awning. Those drones as shown are getting dragged around the sky by their payloads - at best.
-
-
The thing about aerodynamics is, like my other favorite engineering field (electrical), the way it works is extraordinarily difficult to just visualize, though it seems like it should be straightforward. It can be unintuitive.
Show this thread -
Quadcopters - drones with 4 props like that - are popular in part because they can be easily flown with only a very basic feedback-control system that makes these much more tractable than the equivalent programming (to control an airplane or helicopter of the same scale, say)
Show this thread -
A lot of what we are doing with drones uses the quadcopter as a jumping-off point, but ignores aerodynamics. There are a lot of 1-lb bumblebees out there, in aerodynamic terms.
Show this thread -
(There are even a few 10-, 100- and 1000-lb bumblebee designs buzzing around.. with enough power, anything could get off the ground. But they will all fly for longer and further with just a little thought given to the wings.)
Show this thread -
Consider for example, how hard it would be to make your car take to the air. You could floor it, drive it as fast as you wanted - and it would still fly quite poorly. But with wings added, this all changes. It’s aerodynamics, not power, that matter.
Show this thread -
I still feel somewhat responsible for the prevalence of the “Drone brings you stuff” idea, so please consider this thread as sponsored by TacoCopter. I leave you with my so far all-time favorite tweet:https://mobile.twitter.com/GreatDismal/status/185092120376393729 …
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
As depicted yes.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.