why would reviewers agree? We often choose them precisely because they believe different things. @hansijzerman @FGabarrot
-
-
-
Yes, I think what we want to know is the reliability of the outcome of the review process. But I'm not too optimistic about that, either...
-
I agree on the first part. I just want to stay optimistic on the second :)
-
I admire your optimism :) My pessimism comes from seeing many pub'd papers I can't imagine accepting & assuming most editors feel this way.
-
and that also goes for the reverse (seeing papers as reviewer that are not accepted by editors). Reliability of the review process of course goes two ways.
কথা-বার্তা শেষ
নতুন কথা-বার্তা -
-
-
Isn't selection at higher-impact journals mostly achieved through desk rejection by editor?
-
Yes - that also cuts out the lower end of the quality distribution. Works well if you have a balanced and responsible editor as in
@EJPBlog, but also has a huge potential for bias if you give so much power into a single person's hands. -
-> I guess there are many cases of journals/editors where some distributed quality control would be better instead of a lone man's decision (to put it in an exaggerated nutshell)
-
I am therefore surprised that when discussing the gatekeeper function, most people focus on (criticise) peer review but rarely look at the role of editors
-
I agree. I think editors play a bigger role (and should, if they’re doing their job right and not just counting up reviewers’ votes).
-
I think their biggest influence (at least for high impact journals) is deciding whether to send out a paper for peer review in the first place
কথা-বার্তা শেষ
নতুন কথা-বার্তা -
-
-
ধন্যবাদ। আপনার সময়রেখাকে আরো ভালো করে তুলতে টুইটার এটিকে ব্যবহার করবে। পূর্বাবস্থায়পূর্বাবস্থায়
-
-
-
Maybe increasing N of pre-print reviews would help as much as increasing the N of the study. Perhaps equally resource intensive / research slowing but as effective?
ধন্যবাদ। আপনার সময়রেখাকে আরো ভালো করে তুলতে টুইটার এটিকে ব্যবহার করবে। পূর্বাবস্থায়পূর্বাবস্থায়
-
লোড হতে বেশ কিছুক্ষণ সময় নিচ্ছে।
টুইটার তার ক্ষমতার বাইরে চলে গেছে বা কোনো সাময়িক সমস্যার সম্মুখীন হয়েছে আবার চেষ্টা করুন বা আরও তথ্যের জন্য টুইটারের স্থিতি দেখুন।