On a related note, a poll (You have to reply, yes/no is worthless here): Is there such thing as a superior language? Is it meaningful to say that English is better than, say, Mandarin? My answer is yes. (Possible crit.: informational efficiency, beauty, nuance)
I think you could call a language 'superior' within a particular context and people would understand what you mean. It would be meaningful. But if you lived in China, would it be more useful to know English or Mandarin? We tend to choose languages based on proximity.
-
-
Yes, but that's not that interesting to me, in that case one could design a contrived language and it would be useful to know if among people who only speak that. A good framing is: If you could pick a single language for everyone to speak, what would that be
-
Difficult to imagine a contrived language replacing one embedded within a group of people. Personally I find it interesting how good idioms/slang from other languages or cultures travel. That captures what I think is important: language is best when playful compression.
- 2 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.