-
Conditional on AGI extinguishing humanity, lost jobs are hardly more important. So this argument only makes sense if you think AGI is impossible or alignment is easy. So you should just argue that claim; the part about jobs is irrelevant.
#thelastderail https://twitter.com/AndrewYNg/status/1006204761543081984 … -
"Lol, status-as-ontological-weight? I guess that explains
#thelastderail. It's not that they're trying to distract you from the apocalypse by pointing to inequality, they think they're lowering the probability of AGI ruin by performing lowering its status." -
Another entry in the "But why worry about absolute and final ruin if self-driving cars?" campaign
#TheLastDerail https://www.fastcodesign.com/90137818/dear-elon-forget-killer-robots-heres-what-you-should-really-worry-about … -
We can recover from tyrannical world governments and AI-assisted war. We cannot recover from unaligned ASI. It's that simple.
#TheLastDerailShow this thread -
For context, I have a growing suspicion that less-than-full-fidelity memetic spread of "OMG, AGI" has causally brought humanity closer to building unsafe AGI sooner - Legg, Musk, etc. I don't claim that deployers of
#thelastderail are being *strategic*, but they might be helping. -
Notice how all the headlines in the
#TheLastDerail tag start with the word "forget"? It's almost as thought there's something they don't want you to think about. -
Possibly derived from this Ted Chiang piece in Buzzfeed where it’s more explicitly combined with
#TheLastDerail. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/amphtml/tedchiang/the-real-danger-to-civilization-isnt-ai-its-runaway …Show this thread -
Responding to (the very eminent) Rodney Brooks does not mean I'm not responding to anyone else. And the fact that top names with big resources are resorting to
#thelastderail and#thelaststrawman is object-level news about AGI safety, not just about arguments about AGI safety. -
Chiang is engaged in
#thelastderail : https://mobile.twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/943499850460442625 … -
(Note: Brooks did not use
#thelastderail.) -
Is there a word for this? Hmmm...
@ESYudkowsky#TheLastDerail (source: https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018/ )pic.twitter.com/tE1To8gwp4
-
I wonder if there's an actual PR campaign behind
#TheLastDerail (never mind that apocalypse, whatabout corporations!)https://qz.com/1061404/we-need-to-shift-the-conversation-around-ai-before-elon-musk-dooms-us-all/ … -
https://xkcd.com/1968/ is
#TheLastDerail in a nutshell. I can try to imagine hypotheses, but I'm not sure why Randall Monroe thinks this a clever thing to say. If I wrote a fictional character saying this straight out, I'd be accused of writing a 2D straw character.Show this thread -
Very sensible. But the percentages are irrelevant if there is in fact a category error at the root of the comparison. Admittedly this is an "empiricist or rationalist?" thing, but the "billions die" position is purely conjectural.
#TheLastDerail position is not. -
Silicon Valley Is Turning Into Its Own Worst Fear https://buff.ly/2FzZdCw
#AI#Ethics#TheLastDerail via@ESYudkowsky -
Here's a
#mustread link about#thelastderail posted last week https://buff.ly/2vBTun6 See the rest athttps://buff.ly/2vC891q
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.