another judge interrupts to say they're only looking for relevant and probative statements, seemingly intervening out of pity
-
-
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Judge Shedd: If the number of affected people are less than 10% of all Muslims, is that still a ban on Muslims
1 réponse 1 Retweet 6 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Judge Diaz: How long does this taint last? Jadwat (lawyer) demurs, doesn't really answer, seems like he could cite to McCreary tho
1 réponse 0 Retweet 5 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
There's even a note in the lower court decision that covers this
1 réponse 0 Retweet 4 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Judge Niemeyer says very crankily, "Stick with the hypothetical!"
4 réponses 0 Retweet 6 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Judge King asks what would happen if the president repudiated all of his statements. Judge Shedd: Would it change the result at all?
1 réponse 2 Retweets 9 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Jadwat: A simple repudiation wouldn't do it. Judge Shedd: What if he said he was sorry every day for a year? Laughter in the courtroom
1 réponse 2 Retweets 26 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
(Jadwat says no, because that's not how the Est Clause works)
1 réponse 0 Retweet 6 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
A judge chimed in to bring up that McCreary note I thought of before :|
1 réponse 0 Retweet 6 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Still struggling with nerves, I think, but Jadwat did manage to land a line about seeing that anything is left of the Establishment Clause
1 réponse 1 Retweet 6 j'aime
I think that's really key here to assuaging judges' concerns about stepping all over the executive.
-
-
En réponse à @sarahjeong
Now onto rebuttal. Briefing matters more but holy shit that went so poorly
3 réponses 0 Retweet 13 j'aime -
En réponse à @sarahjeong
I want to take solace in how much that is true, but the old saw is that you can't win a case at oral argument but you can lose one
0 réponse 0 Retweet 3 j'aime
Fin de la conversation
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.