DOJ/Trump lost. Temporary restraining order still in place. Very early stages, long way to gohttps://twitter.com/orezpraw/status/829831030815219712 …
-
-
Will try to aggregate links to better commentary as it appears, later
-
9th Circuit is chucking out the parens patriae theory but not deciding it for now.pic.twitter.com/sSDxvSmfc4
-
Looks like standing comes from the universities. That's interesting and if this stands, it's going to open up a lot of lawsuitspic.twitter.com/JpygoBqsuj
-
Court says Mandel case doesn't mean the EO is not subject to judicial review, it's too sweeping for Mandel to be on pointpic.twitter.com/Fy1mJi4F6i
-
Really interesting to see Obama-era incoherent nat-sec motivated 1st Am cases come back as troubling precedentpic.twitter.com/nkn3587UmJ
-
Like. Humanitarian Law Project's dissent is getting thrown in herepic.twitter.com/DWfvihxKNA
-
Humanitarian Law Project is a case about lists of terrorist designations and "material support" — https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-1498.pdf …
-
HLP sought to give legal training to PKK and Tamil Tigers, and this was deemed material support for terrorism. Government won this case
-
Rules of citation means the cases get cited backwards through time. creates a striking picture here: a line from 9/11 to Japanese detentionpic.twitter.com/wZmqwxRP8V
-
This is the standard that has to be applied to the govt's request. 9th Circuit concludes the government failed at step 1 and 2pic.twitter.com/4jzzeQ2XEH
-
#1 is key here. The 9th Circuit is looking at this case and going, "Yeahhhhh, you guys are going to lose."*
-
* legally speaking, "you guys can't prove that you're likely to win"
-
All aliens in the US have due process rights. And "certain aliens" (they don't specify) attempting to re-enter have due process rights toopic.twitter.com/AKGi41fag4
-
Court throw shade on White House counsel, says there's no evidence that counsel is empowered to supersede the EO with clarifying instructionpic.twitter.com/0pg63dxg8J
-
TRO will continue to be nationwide, and the scope will not be narrowed by the 9th.
pic.twitter.com/JlaxEeBovE
-
9th Cir: TRO might be overbroad but why did you write such a bullshit EO then, stop hitting yourselfpic.twitter.com/CHtwiaqj1l
-
I thought that the situation with Giuliani and the EO reminded me of Lukumi Babalu Aye, let me explainpic.twitter.com/EPPJCjXW4I
-
Lukumi is a case about a Florida municipality that banned the killing of animals not for consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_of_the_Lukumi_Babalu_Aye_v._City_of_Hialeah …
-
The ordinance was targeted at santeria. A santeria church sued.
-
Lot of perfectly good reasons to ban the killing of animals not for consumption. So Hialeah, Florida might have gotten away with it. But.
-
The idiot city council basically filled up the official record with open denunciations of santeria and satanic practices
-
"Hialeah's police chaplain testified that the Church worshiped 'demons'"
-
Basically, they pulled a Giuliani. Got slapped down unanimously by SCOTUS because it was just too stupid
-
Moving onto #2 of the standard for a request for a stay, 9th Cir says govt can't show irreparable harm. Incredible opportunity for shade.
-
And they go for it. Says government can't show any aliens from the named countries have perpetrated terrorist attacks in the US

-
Acknowledges that the 7 countries were named by Congress as countries of concern but says that doesn't justify "urgent need" to stay the TROpic.twitter.com/TBAZHohn4e
-
National security on the one hand. On the other hand, free flow of travel, separation of families, freedom from discrimination.
pic.twitter.com/mte7oYBAMP
-
Throwing in freedom from discrimination last is a really beautiful touch

-
In conclusion, Trump lost today in court, is he tweeting yetpic.twitter.com/T29P9m64mv
- 26 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.