At 3:30, before Oracle had a chance to respond, Judge Ryu ruled against Google's motion. So Oracle shrugged it off.
-
-
ALSUP: You tell the judge, I’d like to give you this, judge, but it's under this protective order... I need to hand you a copy.
-
ALSUP: If you were on the other side, you’d be jumping up and down about how they violated the protective order.
-
ALSUP: I think it's important for you to own up and admit that it’s a violation.
-
ORACLE: Even assuming it’s a violation of the protective order—
-
ALSUP: *exasperated noise*
-
ALSUP: Your firm is one of the biggest litigators in America.
-
ALSUP: Next time you go into a court somewhere and you ask for confidential documents I hope someone raises this.

-
ALSUP: You’re pushing me to the direction that I have to find bad faith.
-
ALSUP: A lawyer like Ms Hurst should have known she did the wrong thing immediately.
-
ALSUP: Ms. Hurst is very experienced and she would have been the first to make a motion. She knew she should not have done that.
-
ALSUP: She just blurted out the two numbers that mattered. She just blurted it out.
-
ALSUP: If she had had the recipe for Coca Cola she could have blurted it out in this court right now.
-
Oracle is trying to skirt around whether it's a violation but their point isn't w/r/t that, it's that a contempt finding is inappropriate
-
Oracle says that if Judge Ryu perceived civil contempt, she was required to certify it to the court. (She did not).
-
Oracle says that Hurst is here and is willing to speak to the court if the court would like her to.
-
Back to Google.
-
Google says that even if there is a bad faith / willfulness requirement, you can find bad faith based on how Hurst reacted in court
-
First, she "dissembled" after Van Nest objected; second, when she saw the reporter later, she didn't do anything
-
Alsup asks why Ryu didn't certify civil contempt.
-
Google says it's because Hurst made excuses.
-
ALSUP: The newspapers come to all these hearings. You just assume there’s a newspaper person in this courtroom.
-
, she tweeted
-
Google waves a piece of paper. "The protective order itself says that if you violate it, you can be subject to a finding of contempt."
-
Oracle says that there was a "huge" amount of information to keep confidential and under seal.
-
ORACLE: This was one arguable mistake made throughout the course of a very complex litigation.
-
Alsup wraps up saying he owes his 11:00 calendar a hearing
-
During trial he said he wanted to take an iPhone panoramic photo of the courtroom lolhttps://twitter.com/eevee/status/779026001787432960 …
-
Google worked so hard to keep the "Google information" and "Apple information" a secret but I found it by searching on, uh, Google
- 1 réponse de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.